Kemp Little
  • Looking for someone?
  • Email us
  • Search
MENU MENU
Insights overview

Corporate · Tax · 12 March 2020 · Rebecca Denton · Amanda Solomon

How early corporate governance mistakes can become deal killers | Startups Magazine

At the start of a company’s life, building a business is all-consuming, especially for founders going it alone. For those with an entrepreneurial background, juggling the quest for investment, continuous product or service development and a huge amount of administration is taxing.

For first-timers, learning to do this on the go is even more tricky. One symptom of this – which happens in many startups – is that, at the earliest stages, founders may make some basic corporate mistakes that cause problems later down the line when they look for investment or decide to exit.

These problems can vary wildly in severity. Poor drafting of documents or failure to properly deal with company administration can usually be corrected later (even if it does require expending legal fees to do so). However, there are circumstances where what may appear at first glance to be a minor corporate governance oversight can give rise to painful tax consequences, potential penalties, or have the potential to put any future investment or sale process at risk.

Because of this, many entrepreneurs dread the due diligence process that accompanies a sale or investment process – where potential investors or buyers put the business under a microscope and scrutinise its financial and legal position. However it needn’t be this way. If the management team gets into the habit of recording corporate activity correctly right from the start and focuses on avoiding the major pitfalls, they can dramatically reduce the chance of a due diligence review revealing something catastrophic.

So, where should founders be extra vigilant?

Maintaining appropriate records

Directors of a company have an obligation under company law to keep certain registers, including a register of members which identifies the shareholders of the company and records when they were issued or transferred shares.

The register of members is the first port of call for anyone looking for evidence of who holds the shares in the company. It is therefore particularly important during a sale that this register is accurate, as a buyer will need to know that it is acquiring all the shares in the company. If mistakes in the register of members are found, lawyers acting for the buyer will often advise their clients to halt proceedings until such errors can be resolved, or require that the shareholders indemnify the buyer for any loss associated with the error. This can cause long delays for both parties, or potentially painful or drawn-out negotiations that detract from the key issues at hand, and may involve the company having to apply for a court order to rectify its register.

Many companies tend to hold their statutory registers electronically – typically as a spreadsheet – which is far more convenient than keeping paper records, but can lead to them being overlooked. Founders should ensure they understand precisely what information needs to be recorded and maintained in the statutory registers, or consider using an online cap table platform (such as Carta).

Share buy-backs

In the early days of a business, founders or valued service providers may be issued shares in the company in lieu of salaries or payments. It’s not uncommon, though, for management teams to change as the company evolves or for service providers to no longer be considered part of the future of the business. Rather than allow such people to retain their shares and participate in the economic growth of the company when they are no longer contributing, many companies put in place shareholders’ agreements with a mechanic allowing the company to buy-back that person’s shares.

However, exercising that mechanic needs to be done properly.  Company law is very prescriptive regarding the steps that must be followed (including when payments can be made for the shares).

A share buy-back which is not carried out in accordance with the process set out under company legislation will be void, which may have the consequence that the relevant shares are still in issue. Discovering during due diligence in the run up to a sale that a shareholder who left the business years ago still holds his shares can have devastating consequences: tracking that person down can be difficult and the whole sale process could be at risk if they prove to be uncooperative. It is highly improbable that any buyer would overlook this issue if it were discovered, or proceed with the purchase until it was resolved.

Additionally, failure to comply fully with a buy-back process constitutes a criminal offence by the company and each of its directors in default, punishable by a prison sentence of up to two years, an unlimited fine or both.

EMI share option schemes

One further issue which can potentially derail a transaction is the discovery of a poorly set up share option scheme.

These schemes are designed to incentivise employees by supplementing their income with the right to acquire shares, which helps businesses retain top talent.  EMI share options schemes are extremely popular as they are particularly tax efficient. They are crucial to fast-growth UK startups, which will typically offer significantly lower base salaries, so much so that some of Britain’s top startups have written to the Prime Minister asking for the cap on EMI schemes to be increased to £100m in revenues or 500 employees.

However, if the scheme has been badly drafted or the correct procedures have not been followed, employees may find that they are paying significantly more tax than expected at exit. Suddenly a prospective buyer has a disgruntled future workforce on its hands, whilst the founders face a large headache and potential deal killer.

For early-stage founders, making sure things are done correctly is a hugely beneficial trait in the long run. Think of recording information as providing tangible value for future investors or buyers – it really will pay off.

First published in Start ups Magazine, read the original blog here.

  • Share this blog

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Need to talk about this?

Rebecca DentonRebecca Denton

Amanda SolomonAmanda Solomon

Get in touch

Sign up for our newsletters

  • Share this Blog

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Other stuff you might like

  1. Data first: How tech startups build trust and tap investment | CityA.M
  2. UK’s Gaming Industry – what are the key considerations and how can Kemp Little help?
  3. Finding the right co-founder for your tech startup | ITPRO.
The hottest topics in technology
  • Adtech & martech
  • Agile
  • Artificial intelligence
  • EBA outsourcing
  • Brexit
  • Cloud computing
  • Complex & sensitive investigations
  • Connectivity
  • Cryptocurrencies & blockchain
  • Cybersecurity
  • Data analytics & big data
  • Data breaches
  • Data rights
  • Digital commerce
  • Digital content risk
  • Digital health
  • Digital media
  • Digital infrastructure & telecoms
  • Emerging businesses
  • Financial services
  • Fintech
  • Gambling
  • GDPR
  • KLick DPO
  • KLick Trade Mark
  • Open banking
  • Retail
  • SMCR
  • Software & services
  • Sourcing
  • Travel
close
The hottest topics in technology
  • Adtech & martech
  • Agile
  • Artificial intelligence
  • EBA outsourcing
  • Brexit
  • Cloud computing
  • Complex & sensitive investigations
  • Connectivity
  • Cryptocurrencies & blockchain
  • Cybersecurity
  • Data analytics & big data
  • Data breaches
  • Data rights
  • Digital commerce
  • Digital content risk
  • Digital health
  • Digital media
  • Digital infrastructure & telecoms
  • Emerging businesses
  • Financial services
  • Fintech
  • Gambling
  • GDPR
  • KLick DPO
  • KLick Trade Mark
  • Open banking
  • Retail
  • SMCR
  • Software & services
  • Sourcing
  • Travel
Kemp Little

Lawyers
and thought leaders who are passionate about technology

Expand footer

Kemp Little

138 Cheapside
City of London
EC2V 6BJ

020 7600 8080

hello@kemplittle.com

Services

  • Commercial technology
  • Consulting
  • Disputes
  • Intellectual property
  • Employment
  • Immigration

 

  • Sourcing
  • Corporate
  • Data protection & privacy
  • Financial regulation
  • Private equity & venture capital
  • Tax

Sitemap

  • Our people
  • Insights
  • Events
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Cookies
  • Privacy
  • Terms of use
  • Complaints
  • Debt recovery charges

Follow us

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • FlightDeck
  • Sign up for our newsletters

Kemp Little LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales (registered number OC300242) and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Its registered office is 138 Cheapside, London EC2V 6BJ. The SRA Standards and Regulations can be accessed by clicking here.

  • Cyber Essentials logo
  • LORCA logo
  • ABTA Partner+ logo
  • Make Your Ask logo
  • FT Innovative Lawyers 2019 winners logo
  • Law Society Excellence Awards shortlisted
  • Legal Business Awards = highly commended
  • Home
  • Our people
  • Services
    • Business restructuring and reorganisation
    • Commercial technology
    • Consulting
    • Corporate
    • Data protection & privacy
    • Digital content & reputation risk
    • Disputes
    • Employment
    • Financial regulation
    • Immigration
    • Innovation
    • Intellectual property
    • Private equity & venture capital
    • Sourcing
    • Tax
    • Travel
  • Resources
  • Insights
  • Covid 19: Your Business Continuity
  • Events
  • About us
    • Who we are
    • Our social responsibilities
    • Our partnerships
    • Join us
  • Contact us
  • FlightDeck
  • LORCA
  • Sign up for our newsletters
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
close
close
close

Send us a message

Fill in your details and we'll be in touch soon

    close

    Sign up for our newsletter

    I would like to receive updates and related news from Kemp Little *

    Please select below any publications that you would like to receive:

    Newsletters

    close

    Register for future event information

      close
      close
      Looking for someone?
      Generic filters
      Exact matches only

      Can't remember their name? View everyone

      • Home
      • Our people
      • Services
        • Business restructuring and reorganisation
        • Commercial technology
        • Consulting
        • Corporate
        • Data protection & privacy
        • Digital content & reputation risk
        • Disputes
        • Employment
        • Financial regulation
        • Immigration
        • Innovation
        • Intellectual property
        • Private equity & venture capital
        • Sourcing
        • Tax
        • Travel
      • Resources
      • Insights
      • Covid 19: Your Business Continuity
      • Events
      • About us
        • Who we are
        • Our social responsibilities
        • Our partnerships
        • Join us
      • Contact us
      • FlightDeck
      • LORCA
      • Sign up for our newsletters
      • Follow us
        • Twitter
        • LinkedIn