Kemp Little
  • Looking for someone?
  • Email us
  • Search
MENU MENU
Insights overview

Trade Marks · Disputes · 6 May 2020 · Charlotte Wilding

Red Bull GmbH v Big Horn UK Limited & others [2020] EWHC 124 (Ch)

In the matter of alleged trade mark infringement by Big Horn UK Limited, Voltino Eood and Lyubomir Enchev (the Defendants) against registered EUTMs of Red Bull (the Claimant).

Background

In February 2018, RB brought infringement proceedings against the Defendants on the basis that they used signs similar to RB’s trade marks on energy drinks and bottled water in the UK and EU (Articles 9(2)(b) and (c) and 9(3)). Note that this judgement concerns the First and Third Defendants only as judgment against the Second Defendant issued in October 2019.

The First Defendant, Big Horn UK Limited, is a UK company set up by the Third Defendant, Mr Enchev (who is the sole director), in May 2017 to sell the goods subject of these proceedings.

Due to various issues (solicitors ceasing representation, failure to participate in CMC and pre-trial review and health issues), the trial eventually took place with Mr Enchev attending via conference call.

Marks

RB Trade Marks Big Horn Signs
EUTM No. 3629342

EUTM No. 52746

EUTM No. 1564301

Link to Second Defendant

In August 2016, the Second Defendant filed an EUTM application for the first device above, which RB opposed (refused registration on 7 January 2019). However, Big Horn energy drinks started to sell in the UK and Bulgaria regardless. RB’s test purchases found the cans were identical in shape and size.

As the First and Third Defendants did not serve any witness evidence or disclosure, the precise nature of their involvement with the Second Defendant was unclear. However, it is not disputed that the First Defendant imported and sold energy drinks in the UK and Mr Enchev was the “controlling mind”.

At trial, Mr Enchev said he started negotiations with the Second Defendant in April 2017 to be a distributor of the Big Horn energy drinks. A contract (undisclosed) was entered in to in May 2017 and terminated on 1 March 2019 (although advertising was ongoing after termination).

Article 9(2)(c)

Given the marks cover the same goods and are visually and conceptually similar, the Judge found that the Big Horn signs would cause the average consumer to link those signs with RB’s trade marks. As there was no evident due cause, use of the Big Horn signs took unfair advantage of the distinctive character and reputation of RB’s trade marks.

The Judge held “it is quite evident that Big Horn’s signs have been designed so as to enable Big Horn to free-ride on the reputation of Red Bull, and to benefit from the very considerable marketing efforts of Red Bull to create a particular image associated with its trade marks”.

Article 9(2)(b)

The Judge declined to consider likelihood of confusion in detail, but said he “would not have been persuaded that the Big Horn signs give rise to a likelihood of confusion …Rather, it [is] far more likely that the average consumer would perceive the Big Horn products as cheaper or alternative versions of Red Bull’s products, stimulating sales of the former in a way that would not have occurred had the Big Horn signs not evoked so directly the visual and conceptual forms of the Red Bull trade marks”.

Decision

Accordingly, use of the Big Horn signs infringed RB’s rights under Article 9(2)(c).

Further, being the sole director, Mr Enchev was liable with Big Horn UK Limited as a joint tortfeasor.

Key Points

  • a finding of unfair advantage to the distinctive character or reputation of a mark does not also mean that there is a likelihood of confusion
  • if you are a sole director, there is a high chance that you will be liable as a joint tortfeasor

This article was first published in the May 2020 issue of CITMA Review, the journal of the Chartered Institute of Trade Mark Attorneys (CITMA). For more information on CITMA, please visit their website here.

  • Share this blog

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Charlotte WildingCharlotte Wilding is the head of trade marks

Get in touch

View the team

Sign up for our newsletters

  • Share this Blog

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Other stuff you might like

  1. Quick Guide for Data Licensees
  2. I’ll fight you for it…settling IP disputes
  3. Brexit Blueprint for Brands
The hottest topics in technology
  • Adtech & martech
  • Agile
  • Artificial intelligence
  • EBA outsourcing
  • Brexit
  • Cloud computing
  • Complex & sensitive investigations
  • Connectivity
  • Cryptocurrencies & blockchain
  • Cybersecurity
  • Data analytics & big data
  • Data breaches
  • Data rights
  • Digital commerce
  • Digital content risk
  • Digital health
  • Digital media
  • Digital infrastructure & telecoms
  • Emerging businesses
  • Financial services
  • Fintech
  • Gambling
  • GDPR
  • KLick DPO
  • KLick Trade Mark
  • Open banking
  • Retail
  • SMCR
  • Software & services
  • Sourcing
  • Travel
close
The hottest topics in technology
  • Adtech & martech
  • Agile
  • Artificial intelligence
  • EBA outsourcing
  • Brexit
  • Cloud computing
  • Complex & sensitive investigations
  • Connectivity
  • Cryptocurrencies & blockchain
  • Cybersecurity
  • Data analytics & big data
  • Data breaches
  • Data rights
  • Digital commerce
  • Digital content risk
  • Digital health
  • Digital media
  • Digital infrastructure & telecoms
  • Emerging businesses
  • Financial services
  • Fintech
  • Gambling
  • GDPR
  • KLick DPO
  • KLick Trade Mark
  • Open banking
  • Retail
  • SMCR
  • Software & services
  • Sourcing
  • Travel
Kemp Little

Lawyers
and thought leaders who are passionate about technology

Expand footer

Kemp Little

138 Cheapside
City of London
EC2V 6BJ

020 7600 8080

hello@kemplittle.com

Services

  • Commercial technology
  • Consulting
  • Disputes
  • Intellectual property
  • Employment
  • Immigration

 

  • Sourcing
  • Corporate
  • Data protection & privacy
  • Financial regulation
  • Private equity & venture capital
  • Tax

Sitemap

  • Our people
  • Insights
  • Events
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Cookies
  • Privacy
  • Terms of use
  • Complaints
  • Debt recovery charges

Follow us

  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • FlightDeck
  • Sign up for our newsletters

Kemp Little LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales (registered number OC300242) and is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Its registered office is 138 Cheapside, London EC2V 6BJ. The SRA Standards and Regulations can be accessed by clicking here.

  • Cyber Essentials logo
  • LORCA logo
  • ABTA Partner+ logo
  • Make Your Ask logo
  • FT Innovative Lawyers 2019 winners logo
  • Law Society Excellence Awards shortlisted
  • Legal Business Awards = highly commended
  • Home
  • Our people
  • Services
    • Business restructuring and reorganisation
    • Commercial technology
    • Consulting
    • Corporate
    • Data protection & privacy
    • Digital content & reputation risk
    • Disputes
    • Employment
    • Financial regulation
    • Immigration
    • Innovation
    • Intellectual property
    • Private equity & venture capital
    • Sourcing
    • Tax
    • Travel
  • Resources
  • Insights
  • Covid 19: Your Business Continuity
  • Events
  • About us
    • Who we are
    • Our social responsibilities
    • Our partnerships
    • Join us
  • Contact us
  • FlightDeck
  • LORCA
  • Sign up for our newsletters
  • Follow us
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
close
close
close

Send us a message

Fill in your details and we'll be in touch soon

    close

    Sign up for our newsletter

    I would like to receive updates and related news from Kemp Little *

    Please select below any publications that you would like to receive:

    Newsletters

    close

    Register for future event information

      close
      close
      Looking for someone?
      Generic filters
      Exact matches only

      Can't remember their name? View everyone

      • Home
      • Our people
      • Services
        • Business restructuring and reorganisation
        • Commercial technology
        • Consulting
        • Corporate
        • Data protection & privacy
        • Digital content & reputation risk
        • Disputes
        • Employment
        • Financial regulation
        • Immigration
        • Innovation
        • Intellectual property
        • Private equity & venture capital
        • Sourcing
        • Tax
        • Travel
      • Resources
      • Insights
      • Covid 19: Your Business Continuity
      • Events
      • About us
        • Who we are
        • Our social responsibilities
        • Our partnerships
        • Join us
      • Contact us
      • FlightDeck
      • LORCA
      • Sign up for our newsletters
      • Follow us
        • Twitter
        • LinkedIn